Howdy, all...
The other night, I recalled that the Monogram 1/48th scale kit of the F-106A turned 40 years old this year, having hit the hobby shop shelves in 1983. I recall this specifically because a college friend was geeked to the max over the kit and bought it as soon as he could get his paws on a copy. We were both attending the summer term at Embry-Riddle that year, and he kept showing me the progress he was making. He dropped one of the missile launch rails and detailed the cockpit with the pilot in the seat.
That model was a constant during the Fall semester. He kept futzing over it incessantly until we finally told him to "finish the damn thing already!" The way the rooms were in that particular dorm was such that they had a small "common" room that connected two rooms into a suite. Well, he occupied that common room as his personal living space. I recall when he painted the model--he closed the doors after supper on Friday night, and emerged in the morning--when he opened the doors, the unmistakable scent of Model Master enamel and thinner rolled out with him. He did a great job, to be sure, but I still wonder how many brain cells he killed during that all-nighter paint session...
Anyway, back to the point...
It was a great time for modelers. Monogram released the F-105G in 1982, the F-106A in 1983, a 1/72nd scale F-105G and EF-111A and a 1/48th scale F-84F in 1984. The 1/48th scale F-101B followed in 1985. And this was just Monogram. Revell released their 1/48th scale B-1B and 1/32nd scale F-14A around the same time, Airfix had their 1/48th scale EA-6B, and Hasegawa released their 1/48th scale F-4, F-15, and F-16 families in 1/48th scale with 1/72nd scale versions to follow in the next several years.
At the same time, we had the 1/72 scale aircraft and armor from ESCI, Hasegawa's 1/72 scale line continued to expand, and Tamiya added to their line of aircraft kits with the 1/48th scale A-10A and F-15A and the 1/32nd scale F-14A.
And this was just in the realm of aircraft models. The scene was similar in armor, ships, and autos. Life was good...
As the years have passed, it is interesting to read the modern takes on these kits. New modelers have become enamored of recessed panel lines and tight, precise fit. Anything less makes the kit undesirable or "unbuildable". A lot of these kits are dismissed out of hand because there are more modern kits available with the aforementioned recessed panel details. I've seen the Tamiya A-10A dismissed as "garbage" and the Hasegawa Phantoms reduced to shelf-sitters due to their age.
As I said last time out, "New and Improved" does not always equate to "Better". Since I'm building one right now, let's look at the Tamiya 1/48th scale A-10A. It is a product of its time when it was released in 1977. It best represents a preproduction airframe--it features the ESCAPAC seat, extended flap guides, and lacks the chaff/flare dispensers in the initial run (the latter were added in the 1991 reissue). So, these days, it gets dismissed as being "not a good kit" simply because of what it is.
It has the dreaded "raised panel line" disease on the wings, tail, and aft fuselage. If you think about it, back in the day that may have been the easiest way for a mold maker to simulate the raised rivet heads that are prevalent on those areas of the A-10A. The forward fuselage has nicely engraved panel lines, so it proves that Tamiya did have the technology to mold them.
Back in the old Usenet days and the rec.models.scale group, the question "What is the best kit of a A-10?" My answer was always the same--What era are you wanting to model? To me, someone wanting an early 1/48th scale A-10A was set with the Tamiya or original Revell kit. For a production Hawg through the Desert Storm period, Monogram's was the best--fit issues, warts, and all. But some modelers don't see it that way--they believe that they need to start with the "best" kit and backdate or update as needed. To me, that's akin to performing a tonsillectomy through the rectum--you create a lot more work and have the potential to cause a lot more problems that you solve instead of starting with an older, but potentially better, kit.
In the years since, a gaggle of new A-10 kits have come down the pike, and, with one exception, they all fall short. The exception? The new Academy 1/48th scale A-10C. And yeah, being a definite fan of the A-10, I bought one. Rumor has it that it may be joined by an A-10A at some point. Me, I hope they decide to shrink it down to 1/72nd scale--both an A-10A and A-10C. Otherwise, I stick with the Tamiya and Monogram kits in 1/48th scale and the Hasegawa 1/72nd scale Hawg kits, thanks...
In the case of the Monogram 1/48th scale Century Series kits, they all (with the exception of the F-104) still stand above the more modern kits. Trumpeter, Kitty Hawk, and Hobby Boss have tried to do the F-100, F-101, F-105, and F-106, but they all fall short. The Trumpeter Hun has an odd inlet shape and vertical tail proportion errors. Kitty Hawk's Voodoos have a rack full of issues, not least of which is being an over-engineered nightmare. Hobby Boss tried, but missed the mark with their F-105's, as did Trumpeter with their F-106. Of all the modern kits, I suppose the best of the lot are the Trumpeter F-106's, but any modeler who sticks with the Monogram kits won't be disappointed.
The F-104, incidentally, is covered quite nicely with the Hasegawa and Kinetic offerings in 1/48th scale...
I guess a lot of this comes from what we had back in the day. Before the Monogram Century Series, we had nothing in 1/48th scale. We did have the F-100, RF-101, F-102, F-105, and F-106 from Hasegawa in 1/72nd scale. And outside that, there were F-104 kits available, executed in various degrees of success.
When I downsized my jets (the first time, 1986), I collected the Hasegawa kits for later construction. They were basically good kits--the shapes were there, the kit out of the box was adequate, and there was room for additional work for those who wished to go the extra mile. The kit cockpits were nowhere near as detailed as we would start to see with the late 1970's Monogram kits, but with closed canopies (and the kits almost always were designed to be built with the canopy closed), they were fine with maybe a few tape or paper seat belts added.
Back in the day, modelers who wanted detailed cockpits and the like expected to do that additional work, including vacuum-forming a new canopy to be posed open to show off that extra work. I recall making a comment to a friend about the Hasegawa cockpit tubs--a generic, three-sided affair with narrow "consoles" that had humps at the forward end. He said they used to vacuum-form copies of those cockpit tubs to use on kits that had no cockpit tub...
And yeah, this is another aspect of the hobby that does reflect when we joined it. These days, new modelers experience such kits as the Tamiya 1/48th scale F-14A or F-4B, or the Eduard Wildcats and Zeros, and anything less leaves them disappointed because they had to do more work. I get it. And as much as I love kits that fall together, they always leave me a little empty, as if I missed something by not having to do even a little bit of problem solving during the process. I guess it is why I'm actually enjoying the ride with the Tamiya A-10A (and the Hasegawa 1/72nd scale A-10A I'm building at the same time).
Once again, there are as many ways to enjoy the hobby as there are people enjoying it. I don't necessarily knock the new breed of modelers when they dis a kit for its age, but I do wish they would see those kits in the context of when they were produced and what they meant to modelers at the time. And maybe, just maybe, they can take one of those older kits and find out what we "old guys" already know...
~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~
Something I also notice--apparently modelers are still unaware of this thing called Scalemates when they cite kit information. For instance, I've seen the Monogram 1/48th scale B-26 Marauder dated to "sometime in the mid-1980's" on one of the YouTube channels--the actual release date was 1978 (I know this because I got one back then when I was out of school with bronchitis). It takes literally a minute to check things like this. Hey, if you hold yourself out as a authority, you need to be accurate with your data...
~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~
I'm expecting an order from Plastic Models Store any time now. If you want kits from the Ukrainian manufacturers at good prices (and don't mind waiting a few weeks), give these guys a try. I've had nothing but great service from them--and they send a little bag of yummy Ukrainian candy with the order! In my last order, I got the Dora Wings 1/48th scale Vengeance, the new ICM 1/72nd scale OV-10, and one of the ClearProp 1/72nd scale Seasprites. This time, I got an early Seasprite, a Modelsvit 1/48th scale F-51H for the FANG collection, and the X-Scale 1/144th scale DC-8-32. Kit prices were some 30-35% better than I could get through the domestic distributors, and I make sure to make the order large enough to qualify for free shipping.
~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~
That's all I have for you tonight. Thanks for reading. Be good to one another, and, as always, I bid you Peace.